open hearted open adoption: book tour

Welcome to my stop on the book tour for our own Lori Holden’s book, The Open-Hearted Way to Open Adoption.

I sang the book’s praise when it first arrived in the mail last month, with a certain thrill and sort of fear at seeing my words in black and white, on paper, when I flipped the book open to chapter one. By chance I landed on a page containing an excerpt from I post I had written over four years ago, just before our daughter was born, before she was “ours.” It was about letting go of fear and insecurity and embracing possibility and vulnerability. Ultimately that post was about opening one’s heart.

I wish I could explore all of the questions proposed by participants on this book tour. Though I planned to answer more, I only had time for two since my answers are long! Click through to see what others are saying about Lori’s book.

Holden encourages adopted parents to embrace an and/both mindset instead of either/or thinking, through a careful process of fostering connections of an adopted child to both first parents and adopted parents. Why do you think this approach helps a child “grow up whole?”

Excellent question. While I’d love to speak with authority on this one, our child is not even four years old and is only now beginning to ask questions about her story. But this approach just makes sense. Lori’s fundamental premise: that adopted children grow up with a split between their biology and biography, and that openness can help heal that split. Openness in spirit — i.e., talking about adoption, celebrating the child’s origins, embracing their first families, acknowledging loss, etc. — can help a child integrate these two fundamentally different aspects of themselves.

A child is born into one family, then raised by another. The child remains part of both families. Yet there’s a disconnect. The child’s first/birth family is still very much a part of the child. And the child is still part of that family, even though s/he’s not there. At the same time, the child is embraced into his/her new family and loved and cherished. Yet all the love in the world can’t make up for what the child has lost — i.e., the opportunity to grow up in his/her family of origin. It’s the one thing I can’t give our daughter, that experience. As full as her life may be, something is inherently missing. But I can help facilitate a connection to that sense of herself. When I embrace our daughter’s first family into my heart, I’m loving a part of her. When we embrace them into our lives, they become our family too.

My daughter didn’t choose to be adopted. The rest of us made that choice for her. She shouldn’t have to choose between her two families, where to place her love or loyalty. She shouldn’t be forced to feel a split in her identity, divided. She is not either part of their family or part of ours. She is both. Always both.

Of course I’m her Mama. And I can’t say it won’t hurt when she tells me I’m not her “real” Mama. But she has another Mama, too. That bond never ends, the love never stops. No one wins if we force her to choose, to pretend she exists in just one family. Most of all, she loses an important part of herself. Our daughter is both the result of her nature and nurture. We can help integrate these two vital parts of her identity. Openness takes away nothing from me, once I acknowledge there are certain things I simply cannot provide. Yet it could mean everything to our daughter, in that her first/birth family is a vital part of who she is. By embracing her birth family as extended family, our daughter shouldn’t ever have to choose between us. She may feel loss, but she should never feel split. Her love should not be divided but rather multiplied. Love is not finite or limited. There is enough to go around. She has a right to feel and express it all, and it’s our job as her parents to provide those opportunities.

As Lori wisely says in a recent post, shifting to a “both/and” paradigm properly puts the child first. “We encourage them to claim all pieces of themselves, those from biology and those from biography. We enable our children to be claimed by both of their clans.” An adult adoptee friend puts it more simply: “Not half and half…both things. The two parts are not mutually exclusive nor inclusive. Not 1+1=0…but rather 1+1=1.” She further illustrates the point with this example: a mother with two children is not half a mom to each, but a full mom to both; similarly, adoptees exist in both families at once.

Adoption was once associated with secrecy and shame. Like a dark secret hidden from view, negative emotions can fester beneath the surface which can cause problems later. As Lori writes, openness can help shine a light on that darkness, calling it out, validating those feelings and naming them. Trust and open communication about adoption can help a child approach his/her parents to discuss tough issues in a safe and supported setting, rather than feeling stifled. While we can’t take away or “fix” our children’s negative feelings, we can hold them close and affirm them and help them release those feelings so they don’t insidiously gain power and influence over their hearts and minds.

To me, that’s how openness helps heal. It places the child first, always, even (especially?) when it pushes us beyond our comfort zone. It broadens our definition of family. It supports our children as they work through what it means to be adopted. It helps them claim their full identity, as part of both families. And it means they never have to choose.

Lori talks about her journey as an adoptive mom from initially feeling threatened at the prospect of openness to embracing it as a way to help her children be whole. How important do you think her experience during adoption school (when she was ‘the baby’) was to her process?

The short answer: a little empathy can go a long way.

I can’t speak to Lori’s process, but I can imagine that in those moments — where she imagined what it was like to have been “the baby” separated from the only mother she ever knew — engendered great empathy. Lori’s heart was open enough to get outside her own skin and limited experience, to ponder the heart and needs of the baby. And that’s how we put children in adoption first. We focus on their needs, from before they are born and throughout life. [EDITED to add: Of course all parents ideally do this, adoptive or not. Yet parents through adoption have an unique set of complex issues and relationships to navigate in parenting, which warrant special attention and care.]

I know during our process, my heart opened to embrace openness farther and faster than I could have imagined before. Yet there is a difference between approaching openness objectively — i.e., envisioning it in theory — and subjectively — i.e., living it daily. I can be logical and analyze why openness would be beneficial, but nothing could really prepare me for those intimate moments, sitting with my daughter and telling her how she came to be ours. That’s not to say I shouldn’t have prepared for those moments — because I did, I practiced and started telling her story long before she could ever understand, for instance. Yet in those moments, looking into her bright eyes and feeling the weight of her body against mine as she seeks little bits of information, only that which she is ready to hear and saving the rest for another time, in those moments I want to hold her tight and wipe away the hurt, even the hurt she might not yet feel because the magnitude of her story has not yet been processed. But I know I can’t.

Instead, my job is to hold that space for her to feel and process whatever emotions arise. It’s acknowledging that the day I gained a daughter, she lost a mother. Even as her birth mama remains an integral part of her life, our daughter lost the chance to grow up in the same home. Loss is loss. Acknowledging this validates her experience.

In those moments, I am so grateful for the relationships we have with our daughter’s first family, and I hope and wish and pray they remain strong for her sake. I wonder how accessible her birth mama will be as our little girl grows up and her questions (and understanding) grow more complex. I think about her biological father’s side of the family, and I wonder whether there will ever be more, and quite honestly, I worry about it either way. I think about how one day, she will explore such profound questions and deep issues so core to her very identity. I try to imagine her head and heart trying to grasp the reality of having been adopted, of being adopted. And all I can do in those moments is remember to breathe, open my heart a little more, and let it grow to make room for all of it.

Empathy above all is a quest for understanding. While I can never truly understand what it means to be an adopted child, I can seek understanding by opening my heart to our daughter as she discovers and experiences what it means for her. When I focus on her, everything becomes more clear. This is true now, just as it was before she was born. When I could set aside my longing to become a mama and focus instead on the well-being of the child yet-to-be-born, her interests and needs came first and it became clear what I needed to do. I can only hope the same internal compass will guide me as she grows, along with her understanding of her own story.

~ by luna on May 9, 2013.

11 Responses to “open hearted open adoption: book tour”

  1. Great post Luna! I appreciate reading what you contributed to Lori’s awesome book and also what you have shared here. You truly have a way with words and this really speaks to me today:

    “My daughter didn’t choose to be adopted. The rest of us made that choice for her. She shouldn’t have to choose between her two families, where to place her love or loyalty. She shouldn’t be forced to feel a split in her identity, divided. She is not either part of their family or part of ours. She is both. Always both.”

    Well said.

    I agree that “a little empathy goes a long way” and that reminds me of when my sister (who also contributed to the book) and brother-in-law were navigating a pre-birth match in November 2011 how my family touched base with Lori for advice. She suggested we do our best to look at the situation from the perspective of the baby. Wow! That had never occurred to me and many in my family and made so much sense.

    I love that open adoption above all else embraces being child-centered, something that was missing in a big way during the closed era.

    Another part of your post which struck me is how you describe your job as your adopted daughter’s mother being “to hold that space for her to feel and process whatever emotions arise. It’s acknowledging that the day I gained a daughter, she lost a mother. Even as her birth mama remains an integral part of her life, our daughter lost the chance to grow up in the same home. Loss is loss. Acknowledging this validates her experience.”

    As someone who has lived through a lot of loss, this warms my heart, as it means so much to me when people in my life acknowledge the loss I have experienced, it is, as you say, so very validating.

    Finally, I love, love, love your last paragraph… I won’t cut and paste it all here, but agree “empathy above all else is a quest for understanding” and I believe Lori’s Open-Hearted Way to Open Adoption will help so many to understand more what it means to be part of the adoption constellation and how that knowledge can help them to raise children whole.

  2. This was such a wonderful post. I loved reading about how you tell your daughter her story and how you leave the space for her to learn more as she gets older and the space for her to process it as well. I can only imagine the love that has come from the involvement with the first family and the love and understanding that will come as your daughter gets older.

  3. Excellent post Luna! Thank you so much for sharing.

  4. This line, right here, really says it all:

    “Her love should not be divid­ed but rather mul­ti­plied.”

    Your daughter is a very lucky girl. I’m sure one day she will be as eloquent a champion of open adoption as you are now and the community will be as fortunate to have her as it is to have you.

  5. Hi from the book tour!

    I LOVE this post – it’s beautiful and very touching.

    1st question – I remember reading about the “letting go” in the book and this really resonated with me. I thought a lot about when I was able to let go of some of the difficult emotions related to “letting go” of the dream of a biological child.

    I love how your response ties together the letting go aspect of things to healing. The way Lori wrote about affirming and validating our children’s difficult emotions related to their adoption in order for them to heal was a good reminder that we need to work through the tough stuff, even when it’s rough. This will help us all let go and move forward.

    2nd question – This made me cry. Oh my god, you have put into words what I have been feeling since the day my daughter was born. I too hope for my daughter’s sake that our relationship with her birth mama remain strong and worry about what openness would look like with or without her birth father. I worry about all the tough questions she will have and I want so badly to erase all of the hurt she may feel. I want her to feel nothing but good feelings and it breaks my heart to think that she will have tough stuff to process. But you’re so right – it’s our job to provide a space for them to process the tough stuff and help them heal.

    From your newest follower! 🙂

  6. Thank you for sharing! As an adoptee it warms my heart to see how fortunate it is for adopted children today because their parents have so many resources (like Lori’s book and online communities) besides just the social worker from the adoption agency. I am sure my parents would have approached the idea of being a bit more open if the idea was presented to them.

  7. I’d like to mention that the spirit of Luna is infused in this book, more than just the stories you entrusted to it. Over the years, you and other open-hearted parents have helped me form the thoughts and concepts that were presented here. As Heather said, “it’s the adoption book the Internet wrote” — with heavy doses of Luna.

    I’m so glad someone asked the question about me being the baby in that exercise, and now that I think about it, I wonder if this is where openness first took root in me. As you say, a little empathy goes a long way.

    Thanks for sharing the ride with me, and for the beautiful Amazon review. XOXO

  8. Dear Luna, you have such a way with words. I read your post at least twice just to take it all in.

    I can’t imagine how nervous you were to see your story in print, but it turned out beautifully. And, um, would you be open to posting your family tree in the nursery here so those of us who may want to embark on a similar project would have it as an example? The description of it sounded so, so cool.

    A little empathy CAN go a long way, and reading Lori’s book and all of the thoughtful conversations its encouraged here is prompting me to find some time with my mom to have a little talk. If there is one thing I am guilty of, it’s a lack of empathy there. She’s born the brunt of my anger and hurt, but never really got to hear/feel the resolution. I have never circled back around and said, “i understand.” She assumes all of our conflict comes from her being a “secondary” mother, and that’s not the case. But I could do a much better job at separting and clarfying the issues.

    So, thank you.

  9. […] am deeply grateful to Mel, Kathy,  April, Luna, Jessica, Geo-Chick, BabySmiling, m, Esperanza, Leah Jane, Anne,  Andy, Liz, and Alicia for […]

  10. Beautiful. Thank you. I have been reading for years and learning a great deal from you and Lori. Our little girl is 2 years old. I would say I was predisposed to your way of approaching adoption but I definitely needed those like you to share your experience and thoughts so that I could better understand and begin to embody those ideals for myself. Thank you.

  11. I love the basic philosophy behind the book. It’s taken me in a new mental direction with our adoption and a deep commitment to healing the schism. I love how Lori takes herself out of the emotional equation and allows her children (like you do) to feel and ask and question without letting her own thoughts get in the way. Such a big lesson.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: