Gearing up for our home study visit on Friday, I realized that aside from cleaning our house, there’s not much we can do. Except get some fresh flowers. And someone suggested baking cookies (probably not going to happen). But there’s not really anything more we can do to prepare for the experience of being interviewed about our stability and “fitness” to parent.
We’ve already discussed the hard questions and answered in writing. But that’s much different than answering in person. I, for one, am usually more comfortable writing about difficult issues than talking about them, at least when it’s personal. And this is about as personal as it gets, aside from spreading my legs for a total stranger in a paper gown under fluorescent lights surrounded by onlookers. Oh right, I’ve done that too… Is nothing sacred anymore?
Rebeccah at Chasing a Child recently had an excellent post about the incredibly invasive nature of the adoption home study process. She wrote about the expectation that you should be prepared to “pry open your soul and lay it on the table” for inspection. She said something else that resonated — that while infertility treatment was also a very invasive process, there were boundaries that enabled her to protect her heart and mind from exposure and scrutiny.
It’s so true. There are no such boundaries in this process. There is no division between personal and private. Everything is fair game, subject to scrutiny. Our feelings are our own and we have to deal with them, but here they are to be judged by people with the power to make us parents.
I understand the need for certified professsionals to verify that we are not criminals, and that we would provide a permanent loving home for a child. I appreciate the need to ensure that we would not physically or psychologically harm our child. But I have a hard time with the intense scrutiny of every little detail of my life, heart and mind, particularly where I doubt its relevance to my ability to parent. (I can’t even begin to tell you how mad it makes me that a single person or gay couple could encounter even greater restrictions…)
M and I don’t have anything to hide. We’re committed to telling the complete truth. But for me that’s not even the point.
We would expect to be asked about how we came to our decision to adopt, our views on discipline, etc. We would even expect to be asked for proof of finances or income. Yet here are just some of the questions I’ve heard asked, with detailed answers expected: Tell me about your parents; Tell me about your infertility; Tell me about your grief; How do you feel about not being able to have biological children?; What are your fears about open adoption?; Tell me about your sex life. Excuse me?
Tell you about my grief. Hmm. Do you want the long or the short version? I suppose it bears repeating. I will never “get over” the grief of losing my son. I may always grieve the biological children we never had. But I’ve made a conscious choice to try to move past it, to move forward. Because I want to be a mother. To the extent that my grief for my lost child/ren would affect my ability to parent my future child, I get it. But this is not a psychologist making that determination.
How do I feel about not being able to have a biological child? Well, it sucks. It’s a significant loss. But does that mean I would not unconditionally love a child who had been carefully entrusted into our care? Absolutely not. I’m committed to becoming a parent, and our child will be our child.
I was on an adoption board recently, reading about someone’s home study in which the couple had been asked about their sex life (and she was not the only one). Now I’m hardly prudish, but I was offended by the question. How the hell is that relevant? Is the social worker trying to determine the stability of the marriage based on how frequent or good the sex is? Is she even qualified to make a judgment whether both people are satisfied? On the board, most women said “who cares? it’s fair game and I have nothing to hide!” But tell me, what happens if I say “excuse me, but can you tell me how that is relevant here?” Seriously, I want to know.
I should add that we’re not really sweating the home study, even though it’s a lot of work. I just don’t want to resent the invasiveness of the process any more than necessary.
To anyone else who has been through this, what’s the strangest question you were asked in your home study, and how did you respond?









